DIY vs. Hiring a Handyman: When to Call a Pro
Maintaining a rental property is a constant balancing act between cost, time, and quality. As a property owner or manager, you may be tempted to tackle repairs yourself to save money. But not all repairs are created equal—some DIY fixes can turn into costly mistakes, while others are easy wins. In this guide, we’ll break down when you should DIY vs. hire a handyman to keep your property in top shape.
When DIY Makes Sense
For minor repairs and maintenance tasks that don’t require specialized tools or expertise, DIY can be a great way to cut costs and handle issues quickly. Here are a few scenarios where handling it yourself is reasonable:
✅ Basic Repairs & Maintenance
- Replacing air filters and smoke detector batteries
- Unclogging sinks or toilets with a plunger
- Tightening loose cabinet handles or door hinges
- Touching up paint or patching minor drywall holes
✅ Simple Plumbing & Electrical Fixes
- Replacing a showerhead or faucet aerator
- Swapping out light bulbs or basic fixtures
- Resetting tripped circuit breakers
✅ Landscaping & Curb Appeal
- Trimming small bushes and plants
- Pressure washing the driveway
- Replacing house numbers or mailbox labels
These types of tasks don’t require permits, special skills, or expensive tools. As long as you’re comfortable handling them, they can be quick and inexpensive DIY jobs.
When to Call a Handyman
Some repairs require professional expertise to avoid costly mistakes, liability risks, or even code violations. Here’s when you should bring in a handyman or licensed contractor:
🚨 Plumbing & Electrical Work
- Major leaks or pipe repairs – DIY attempts can lead to flooding or water damage.
- Faulty outlets or wiring issues – Electrical work can be dangerous if done incorrectly.
- Water heater issues – Repairs often require specialized knowledge and tools.
🚨 Structural Repairs
- Fixing doors that don’t close properly – This may involve adjusting the frame, which requires precision.
- Drywall repairs larger than a few inches – Patching and retexturing take skill to blend seamlessly.
- Fence or gate repairs – If posts are broken or panels need replacing, a handyman can ensure a sturdy fix.
🚨 Safety & Code Compliance
- Smoke/CO detector installation and testing – Local laws may have specific requirements for placement.
- Stair and railing repairs – A loose railing is a liability and should be fixed correctly.
- Tripping hazards – Uneven sidewalks, loose pavers, or damaged flooring should be professionally repaired.
🚨 Lock & Security Fixes
- Rekeying locks between tenants – A locksmith or handyman can quickly swap out or rekey locks.
- Fixing jammed or misaligned locks – Ensuring doors close and lock properly is critical for tenant safety.
Need a Handyman for Your Rental Property?
Knowing when to DIY and when to call a handyman can save you time, money, and headaches. If you’re unsure whether a repair is within your skill set, it’s always better to err on the side of caution and bring in a professional. At QuickTurn Maintenance, we specialize in rental property repairs and can handle everything from lock changes to code compliance fixes. Let us take the hassle out of property maintenance so you can focus on growing your real estate investment.
